To ease any of those tensions, review sites (including ourselves,) set up a pros and cons list at the end of every review. Not many people understand what the use of this actually is. Or I’d like to believe they don’t, judging by some of the responses we receive. The pros and cons list ties directly into what was stated above. It’s not only a quick summary (for the people who refuse to read reviews then rage at the reviewer) but it’s there for the reader to decide if they think the issues the reviewer displayed fit their own gaming mold. The reviewer’s positive aspects may be the reader’s negative aspects or vice versa. Then from there, the reader can easily decide if the game is worth their time.
Through the past few years, review scores have somehow gone through an immense transformation. The numbers haven’t changed, but the people’s opinions towards those same numbers have. Do we have to lower ourselves back into the thumb rating system? “I give this title two thumbs up!” I really hope not. It appears with the complaints some review scores receive; this might be the way we have to go. Roger Ebert would be proud. Do you really want to see a game receive a fully erect thumb and a semi-risen “halfway there” thumb as a review score? Why have these changes come about, and what exactly are they?
10/10 (Perfect): A very rare rating, but given to games that have little to no debilitating issues.
9/10 (Excellent): The game is plagued with a mild issue that may bring about issues with some players.
8/10 (Great): Usually games lacking replay value and a lengthy story, but still contain a worthwhile experience receive this score.
7/10 (Average): A game is lacking certain necessities, and is presented in an underwhelming manner, but a positive experience should still be obtained.
6/10 (Bad): There may be some bugs and the game may feel unfinished, but not completely unplayable.
5/10 (Awful): Uninteresting story, poor mechanics, mild bugs, glitchy visuals, lacking replay value usually render this score.
4/10 (Mediocre): A completely broken game. The game lacks all of the necessities for a proper game. Story, visuals, sound, controls, etc that, in return, makes a frustrating and almost unplayable experience.
Nothing ever went below a 4/10. There was no use to ever document such a travesty. Seeing a rating below a 4/10 was like encountering Mew.
10/10 (Perfect): But probably a result of a biased or “paid-off” review.
9/10: (Amazing): But only because it’s a sequel to a well-liked franchise.
8.5/10 (Great): Because, nowadays, that .5 makes an enormous difference in the general opinion.
8/10 (Terrible): The .5 is gone so now it's just freaking awful! I’m only going to rent this now!
7/10 (Suckage): The ultimate suckage! Just absolutely atrocious! This game is a waste of time!
Everything possible has been tried. We, the reviewers, have fused the numbers with one simple word to describe the game, added pros and cons lists, and even closing comments, but those numbers, no matter what, receive a great deal of backlash. Since the numbers are what are giving certain people so many issues, the only resolution I have devised is to just dump the numbers entirely. People would be more susceptible to NOT have an outburst if a game receives a “Good” rather than if it received an 8/10 (which in my eyes, there’s no difference between the two). No matter if you tag “Good” after the rating of 8/10, people still cry foul, so why not just drop the number score altogether?
Some folks have dropped the numbers by using letter grade reviews, but even those receive backlash. I’m beginning to believe it’s just internet trolls gaining a sense of entertainment from causing a raucous. At least that would make it more explainable. Certain reviewers have switched to the letters grading system because, it’s a pretty universal notion that in grade school an A is great, a B is good, a C is average – and well, you know the rest. And I feel people feel the need to break those letter grades down further like so:
F: 59% or lower
And I think that’s where the issue arises. People, no matter the circumstance, will denote the letter grade to a number grade. It’s the same people that call blasphemy at an 8/10 (80%) that outrage at a game receiving a B, because in their eyes, they’re identical. Which is fine, but I hope they didn’t flip out at their teachers because the teacher gave them an 87% on their research paper on how the Pilgrims came to America instead of a 90%. “I didn’t GIVE you an 87, you EARNED it!” For some odd reason, I kind of do feel like the people who rage at an 8/10 are the ones who raged at their teachers because they received an 87 and not a 90. Video games aren’t “copy-and-paste-then-change-up-some-words” jobs like your essay. Calm down!