PDA

View Full Version : Another Reason Why Gamespot Reviews Suck



Gunpei
09-20-2003, 06:43 PM
Regarding GameSpot's review of Savage: The Battle for Newerth

This message is to state that the editors of GameSpot have decided to rescind the recently posted review of the PC game, Savage: The Battle for Newerth. This decision comes as a direct result of allegations by the game's developers that the reviewer of the product did not play it for a sufficient length of time prior to passing judgment --an allegation supported by specific server-side player logging that apparently measures exactly for how long the player's account was active.

While we have no way of substantiating this allegation ourselves, as we have no access to the same tools or information that the game's developers do, we nonetheless have taken and are taking this claim very seriously, and have discussed it in detail with the author of the review. He, in turn, takes the accusation very seriously--having written dozens of articles for GameSpot over the years, this author has certainly helped bolster our credibility with our audience over the long run. Nevertheless, as the author cannot produce sufficient evidence to counter the allegation (though he has not pleaded guilty to it, either), we are compelled to take the actions we believe are necessarily in the best interest of GameSpot and its users.

We are, now and always, firmly committed to providing our users with unequivocally accurate information about games--information that is deeply rooted in fact, and unadulterated by any biases from any parties. That is, we are committed to looking out for our users' time and our users' money, and we would never willfully post any article on this site that we knew to be in poor judgment or not based on a sufficiently experienced evaluation of the product in question. As such, we sincerely regret that this situation has come to pass, and trust that you, our users, understand why we have chosen to take this course of action, despite the decided ambiguity of the circumstances. We will re-evaluate Savage: The Battle for Newerth at a later date, using all due care and diligence as we consistently work to apply in all cases.

Greg Kasavin / Executive Editor, GameSpot

Michael Bluth
09-20-2003, 06:54 PM
Kasavin is the worst reviewer ever. And Gamespot sucks for reviews, but they have pretty good news.

Gunpei
09-20-2003, 06:56 PM
i hate their site layout too. its so fucking hard to navigate that site.

Prince
09-20-2003, 11:06 PM
haha they got fucking owned. I'm surprised he made it public (but maybe he was threatened by the publisher and had to make it public, or the publisher would?). I wonder how much of this stuff happens behind closed doors.

OnBake Platinum
09-20-2003, 11:12 PM
You know a site that sucks more? www.nintendonow.com TRASH! Their forums are full of dumbasses too.

Gunpei
09-21-2003, 01:58 AM
Yeah, we should SPAM that POS forum.

smellslikenintendospirit
09-21-2003, 03:16 AM
If you want reviews, go to Gamespy. IGN rates 'em too high, Gamespot is inconsistent.

And besides...

http://www.wackyweaselworld.com/gamespot/InBed.gif